Best Pizza in Brownsville, Brooklyn

Q: Where are you located?

We are located in Brooklyn, NY at 1686 Pitkin Ave

Old-school Brooklyn pizza on Pitkin Avenue

Order online

Featured

View menu

1686 Pitkin Avenue

For years, Sal & Paul's has been part of the Pitkin Avenue neighborhood, serving up old-school Brooklyn pizza and classic pizzeria favorites. Our 1686 Pitkin Avenue location was renovated in July 2018, giving this longtime neighborhood spot a refreshed home while keeping the familiar food and local feel people love. Stop by for a slice, a full pie, garlic knots, wings, pasta, or a cold slushie

Read our Pitkin Avenue story

Garlic Knots, Slices, and More

Grab legendary garlic knots with a blue slushie and a couple of slices, or dig into Buffalo wings, baked pasta, heroes, and plenty of classic pizzeria favorites. Whether you’re stopping by for a quick slice or putting together a full meal, Sal & Paul’s has something for every kind of appetite.

View the full menu

Grandma and Buffalo pies

Grandma Pizza comes thin crust Sicilian with fresh garlic, basil, and hearty tomato sauce. Buffalo Style Chicken is deep dish, loaded with housemade Buffalo sauce and bleu cheese.

See signature pies

Slices at the counter

A Classic Brooklyn Pizza Experience

At Sal & Paul’s, the experience is all about good pizza, familiar favorites, and the easygoing feel of a neighborhood pizzeria. Grab a fresh slice at the counter, settle in with a whole pie, or round out your meal with garlic knots, Buffalo wings, baked pasta, heroes, and a refreshing slushie. Whether you’re stopping by for a quick bite or sharing a meal with family and friends, there’s always something satisfying waiting at 1686 Pitkin Avenue.

Hidden gem is over used, but this place is definitely a hidden gem. Soft pillowy crust with a nice chew, decent sauce and cheese. The garlic knots are legendary. The guys who make the food care and it shows.

leo T.

My uber delivery didn’t brought all my order and when I call the pizzeria, without any hastiaron, they told me that they will deliver it. Less than 10’ after a very attentive man delivers my pizza and apologized for the inconvenience. 👌🏽

Viki F.

I really enjoyed the pizza, I noticed that even with pepperoni it wasn’t dripping grease which is a plus for me The slushies are also really good and I love the way they mix the flavors and even give you that option In a span of one week I have been a few times lol The staff is always kind, thank you guys

I’ve been coming to this pizza show since I was a kid!! It really is a cool place to have a slice of pizza after shopping. It’s family owned, they employ people from the community. This is the truly the best pizza I’ve ever had in the US! The crust is flavorful, smooth and buttery with a crunch heaven to the palate.

MiMi C.

Sal & Paul's Pizzeria Rewards

Join our rewards program, earn points every time you order online and redeem your points for free food!

Join now

Get our free app

Get promotions, track orders, and reorder favorites in seconds.

Get our free app

Get promotions, track orders, and reorder favorites in seconds.

Download now

Frequently Asked Questions

What are you known for?

We are known for Mozzarella Sticks, Penne Alla Vodka, Meatballs, Margherita Pizza, Deep Dish, Wings, Spaghetti, Caesar Salad, Pasta, Pan Pizza, Cheese Pizza, Sicilian Pizza, BBQ Chicken Pizza, Ravioli, Garlic Bread, Salads, and Garlic Knots

What meals do you serve?

We serve Lunch and Dinner

Do you offer delivery or takeout?

Yes, we offer Delivery and Takeout

Where are you located?

We are located in Brooklyn, NY at 1686 Pitkin Ave

What areas do you serve?

We serve the following areas: Brooklyn, New York, Brownsville, Jersey City, Brooklyn Manor, Cypress Hill, Starrett City, Crown Heights, Bushwick, Prospect Lefferts Gardens, Ridgewood, Kings County, Bedford-Stuyvesant, Clinton Hill, Prospect Park, Glendale, East Flatbush, Canarsie, Woodhaven, and Cedar Manor.